Glossy photo paper prints dull — ICC & media settings

Joe B.

Reviewed for technical accuracy

Specialities: Windows 11/10, macOS (Sonoma/Ventura/Monterey), Printers, Color Management, Photo Output

Glossy prints dull or flat — fix ICC profile, media type & color management (HP, Epson, Canon, Brother)

Technician

Hey! Dull glossy photo paper usually means a mismatch between the ICC profile, the media type, and who’s managing color. Tell me your brand — Epson, Canon, HP, or Brother — plus the exact paper (manufacturer/model) and whether you print from Photoshop/Lightroom or an app like Preview/Photos. We’ll make sure the right profile, media setting, and quality mode are selected and that there’s no double color management.

Customer

I’m on macOS Sonoma with an Epson photo printer. Using third-party glossy paper. Prints are flat and lack punch, especially reds. I don’t see where to choose an ICC profile.

Technician

Got it. Glossy prints look dull when:
• The app is using the wrong ICC profile (or none), so colors are mapped to the wrong gamut.
• The printer driver’s media type doesn’t match the paper (e.g., set to Plain instead of Glossy/Photo Paper), which changes ink limits and gloss optimizer.
• Both the app and the driver apply corrections (double color management).
• Quality mode is too low; some papers require High Quality/Photo RPM to fully saturate.
Plan: choose the correct profile, set the Epson Media Type, decide whether the app manages color or the printer manages color, then print a controlled test with the right rendering intent and black point compensation.

Customer

Where exactly do I select the ICC and media type on Mac?

Technician

macOS — use app-managed color with the correct ICC:
1) In Photoshop/Lightroom choose Color Handling → Let Photoshop/Lightroom Manage Colors.
2) Pick the paper’s exact ICC profile (vendor ICC or the closest Epson Premium Glossy/Luster profile). Enable Black Point Compensation; set Rendering Intent to Relative Colorimetric or Perceptual and note which looks better.
3) Click Print Settings → choose your printer → open the Printer Features / Media Type panel → set Media Type to the nearest glossy option and Quality to High/Best Photo.
4) Disable driver color adjustments: set Color Mode = Off (No Color Adjustment). This prevents double color management.

Customer

I also print from Windows 11 occasionally. Same dull look. Where’s the ICC option there?

Technician

Windows 10/11 — match ICC & media type:
• In Photoshop/Lightroom set Color Handling → Application Manages Color and choose the ICC profile for your glossy paper.
• Click Printer Settings → choose the right Media Type (e.g., Premium Glossy) and Quality = High/Max.
• Open the driver’s Color/Advanced tab and set No Color Adjustment / ICM Off. That stops double color management and lets the app handle the ICC transforms.
• If your app can’t pick profiles, use Printer Manages Color and select a matching ICM/ICC in the driver — but app-managed color is usually more accurate.

Customer

I’m using Canon paper on an Epson — no dedicated profile. What’s the best workaround?

Technician

If your paper brand lacks an ICC profile:
• Choose the closest printer-manufacturer profile by surface and weight (e.g., Epson Premium Photo Paper Glossy 255–300 gsm for most third-party glossy stocks).
• Match the Media Type accordingly so ink limits and gloss optimizer are correct.
• Print two small test images, one with Perceptual and one with Relative Colorimetric + Black Point Compensation. Keep whichever yields the best shadow detail and saturation without color cast.

Customer

What about HP and Brother drivers? Any brand-specific tips to avoid dull output?

Technician

HP / Epson / Canon / Brother — glossy color management:
• HP: In driver set Paper/Quality → Media to the glossy type; under Color choose Application Managed Colors or disable HP color enhancements when using ICC profiles.
• Epson: Use Premium Glossy/Luster media, High Quality, and Off (No Color Adjustment) if the app manages color.
• Canon: In the UFR II/Inkjet driver pick the exact Media Type (e.g., Photo Paper Pro Platinum), set Color/Matching to None when the app manages color; otherwise use the corresponding Canon ICC.
• Brother: Select Photo/Glossy media with Best quality; under Color disable enhancements (e.g., Vivid) when printing via an external ICC profile.

Customer

Shadows look muddy and the surface isn’t glossy enough. Any print-time tweaks?

Technician

Try this:
• Increase Quality to the top setting (Best Photo/Photo RPM); some printers add gloss optimizer only at high modes.
• Switch Rendering Intent: Perceptual often boosts saturation; Relative keeps neutrals accurate with Black Point Compensation to protect shadow detail.
• Enable the paper’s dry time option if available and allow 24 hours for complete dry-down on high-gloss stocks.

Customer

Can I soft-proof before wasting paper?

Technician

Yes — soft proof: in Photoshop/Lightroom choose View → Proof Setup (or Soft Proofing) and select the same ICC profile. Toggle Simulate Paper & Ink to preview the reduced contrast of glossy stocks. Adjust with a duplicate proof copy, then print with identical ICC, media type, and quality to match the proof.

Customer

Great — colors finally pop. Could you summarize the settings I should save as a preset?

Technician

Preset for glossy photo paper (ICC & media):
• App manages color → select the paper’s ICC profile.
• Driver: Media Type = matching glossy option; Quality = High/Best; Color = No Color Adjustment / ICM Off.
• Intent = Perceptual (or Relative + BPC if neutrals shift).
• Save as a named preset (e.g., “Glossy – ICC – High Quality”).

Customer

Perfect. My glossy photos look vibrant now. Thanks!

Technician

Summary: If glossy photo paper prints dull, match the ICC profile to your paper, set the correct media type and quality, and avoid double color management by letting the app or the driver — not both — manage color. Adjust rendering intent and enable black point compensation to restore punch and detail. Need help picking the right profile? Open the chat.

Quick answer: the accepted fix

Accepted fix when glossy prints look dull: choose the paper’s exact ICC profile, set the driver Media Type to the matching glossy option with High Quality, and disable driver color when the app manages color (or vice versa) to prevent double color management. Test Perceptual vs Relative + BPC.

FAQ

Step-by-step (Windows 10/11)

1. In Photoshop/Lightroom set Application Manages Color and choose the paper’s ICC profile.
2. Open Printer Settings → select matching Media Type (Glossy/Photo) and Quality = High/Best.
3. In the driver’s Color/Advanced tab select No Color Adjustment / ICM Off to avoid double color management.
4. Print two proofs: Perceptual vs Relative + BPC; keep the better result and save as a preset.

Step-by-step (macOS)

1. Choose Let App Manage Color and pick the paper’s ICC profile.
2. In Print Settings set the driver Media Type to the correct glossy option and Quality to High/Best.
3. Under Color/Matching set Off (No Color Adjustment) when the app manages color.
4. Enable Black Point Compensation, choose intent, soft-proof, and save a preset.

Sources

• Adobe — Print color management
• Apple — Print settings on Mac
• Epson — Drivers & ICC resources
• HP — Photo printing & color management
• Canon — Media type & color matching
• Brother — Photo/ICM driver settings

Matt ● replies in < 1 min

Technician Expert

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Trusted by 27,000+ customers

Alex · Expert's Assistant

Start Chat

5 Tech Support Specialists are online right now.