Joe B.

Expert ★★★★★ 27,853 satisfied customers

Specialities: Photo & fine art printers, B&W printing workflows, Color management, ICC profiling, Epson/Canon/HP drivers

Fix color casts in black & white photo printing — neutral B&W, grayscale modes, paper profiles & ink settings

Technician

Hey! Let’s get your black & white photo prints truly neutral so you can banish green, magenta and sepia tints for good.
To dial in a neutral B&W printing workflow, I’ll ask a few things: What printer model (Epson/Canon/HP etc.) are you using? Are you printing from Lightroom, Photoshop or driver-only? What paper type (RC glossy, luster, matte, fine art, third-party) and which media setting/ICC profile is selected? And are you using any “Advanced B&W” / “Black ink only” / “Grayscale” mode right now?

Customer

I’m on an Epson photo printer, printing from Lightroom. I choose the paper ICC profile, but my black and white prints are slightly green under daylight and a bit magenta under warm light. I just want neutral monochrome prints that look consistent.

Technician

Got it — classic B&W color cast scenario.
A few key causes:

• The driver using colored inks heavily instead of the dedicated gray/black ink channels.
• Double color management (Lightroom managing color + driver color corrections still on).
• Wrong or generic ICC profile / media type for that paper, so the neutral curve is off.
• Metamerism: looks neutral in one light, green or magenta in another.

Our plan is to: 1) lock down a correct B&W workflow (Epson Advanced B&W / Canon B&W / HP grayscale), 2) match paper type & media setting properly, 3) use the right DPI & quality mode so fine detail stays crisp without banding, 4) tweak toning to “neutral” and test under real lighting.

Customer

Makes sense. How exactly should I set Lightroom and the Epson driver so the printer doesn’t add a tint? I’m confused about “Printer Manages Color” vs “Application Manages Color” and the Advanced B&W mode.

Technician

Great question — this is where most neutral B&W print problems start.
Step 1 — Decide who manages color
Option A — Use the driver’s dedicated B&W mode (Epson Advanced B&W, Canon B&W Photo Print, etc.).
In Lightroom/Photoshop: set “Printer Manages Color”. In the printer driver, choose your exact media type, enable Advanced Black & White (or similar), and set tone to Neutral. This leans heavily on black/gray inks for smooth grayscale with minimal color ink, reducing tints.

Option B — Use ICC profiles (Application Manages Color).
In Lightroom: pick a B&W-optimized ICC profile or your paper’s correct color profile, choose Relative or Perceptual, and disable all color corrections in the driver (no “vivid”, no auto enhance). This gives consistent results if your monitor is calibrated and you print often on the same paper.

Customer

I’ve been mixing those — Lightroom managing color plus some Epson color settings. So that’s probably wrong. What about DPI and quality? Do higher settings help neutral B&W prints, or just waste ink?

Technician

Step 2 — Choose smart DPI & quality for crisp, neutral text & tones
For most B&W photo prints on A4/A3:

• Use the printer’s recommended photo quality mode (e.g. 1440×720 or 2880×1440 on Epson; High/Best Photo on Canon/HP).
• Avoid draft/normal text modes — they often mix CMY and can introduce a slight green or magenta cast and grain in smooth gradients.
• Higher quality modes help consolidate dots from the gray/black inks, giving crisp edges and smooth shadows in B&W.

The trick is: not max DPI blindly, but choose the quality preset recommended by the paper vendor for , then keep it consistent.

Customer

I also use third-party matte paper. Could that be causing a warm or cool tone even if settings are right? How do media type and paper white affect neutral B&W?

Technician

Exactly — paper choice and media type are huge for neutral monochrome.

• If you pick the wrong media setting (e.g. “Plain Paper” for a baryta/glossy), the printer lays down the wrong ink load and black curves, often shifting to green or brown.
• Warm-tone papers and papers with heavy optical brighteners can make a technically neutral print appear slightly warm or cool. That’s normal — it’s paper white, not your file.
• For third-party paper, always download their ICC profile & recommended media type for your exact printer. If not available, we can build a safe starting combo and micro-tune with test strips.

We’ll align media type + ICC/profile + B&W mode so your blacks are deep, highlights clean, and midtones neutral instead of muddy or tinted.

Customer

Sometimes the prints look neutral in my room but shift in daylight or gallery lighting. Is that just metamerism or can we reduce it?

Technician

Great observation — that’s metamerism and it’s common with pigment inksets.
To reduce it and keep neutral B&W prints across different lights:

• Use your printer’s Advanced B&W / monochrome mode where available — it’s tuned to minimize color casts and metameric shifts.
• Avoid aggressive “cool” or “warm” tones if you want true neutral; even a tiny bias can exaggerate under gallery LEDs.
• Test under at least two sources: daylight by a window and your target display lighting (LED/halogen).

If needed, we can apply a very slight opposite tint (e.g., tiny magenta compensation for a green cast) at the driver or soft proof level for your specific environment.

Customer

Understood. What’s a simple repeatable process I can follow every time to keep my black & white prints consistent and neutral?

Technician

Here’s a simple neutral B&W workflow you can reuse:

1. Edit your image in a proper grayscale/B&W conversion (no weird color toning unless intentional).
2. Soft proof (if available) with your paper ICC profile to check shadows and highlights.
3. In the print dialog, pick either:
   • Driver B&W mode (Advanced B&W / B&W Photo / K3 etc.) + exact media type, tone set to Neutral, OR
   • Application Manages Color with the correct profile & driver color off.
4. Use the recommended photo DPI/quality, not draft.
5. Print a small B&W test strip with ramps and skin tones before large prints.

Once this is dialed for one paper, you can quickly adapt it for others without chasing mystery tints each time.

Customer

That’s helpful. I’m also running a small lab. Any extra steps for more “pro” level consistency across multiple printers and papers?

Technician

Yes — for studios and labs wanting rock-solid neutral black & white photo printing:

• Calibrate and profile your monitors to a consistent white point (e.g. D50 or D65) so “neutral” on screen matches “neutral” on paper.
• Standardize on a small set of papers with good B&W performance and vendor ICC profiles.
• Use the same B&W driver mode and media settings on all printers of the same model.
• Run periodic nozzle checks and basic maintenance; missing nozzles can cause odd shifts in deep grays.
• Document your exact settings so staff can repeat them instead of guessing per job.

If you’d like, an Expert can walk through your specific printers and lighting and build a documented neutral B&W workflow for your lab.

Customer

Perfect — that explains the tints. With your settings my test prints look neutral under both daylight and LEDs. Thanks!

Technician

Summary: To get neutral B&W photo prints and banish unwanted tints, avoid double color management, use the correct media type and ICC profile, enable your printer’s dedicated B&W/Advanced Black & White mode or a clean ICC workflow, choose suitable DPI/quality, and test on the paper you actually use. This combination stops random green/magenta casts and gives consistent, gallery-ready monochrome prints. Want help tuning it for your exact printer and paper? Open the chat.

Quick answer: the accepted fix

Accepted fix for unwanted tints in black & white photo prints: choose one color-management path (driver B&W mode or application + ICC), match the correct media type & paper profile, use photo quality/DPI instead of draft, and print B&W test strips under your real lighting. This stabilizes neutral monochrome output and eliminates random green, magenta or brown casts.

FAQ

Step-by-step: get neutral B&W photo prints

1. Convert your image to a clean black & white file (no leftover color casts).
2. Pick the correct paper profile & media type for your printer/paper combo.
3. Choose either:
   • Printer Manages Color + Advanced B&W/B&W Photo mode set to Neutral, or
   • Application Manages Color + correct ICC + all driver color options off.
4. Set an appropriate photo DPI/quality (not draft).
5. Print a small test strip; verify neutrality in your target lighting; adjust toning if needed.

Note for macOS & mixed environments

1. On macOS, ensure you’re not letting both the app and system dialog apply color adjustments.
2. Use printer-specific B&W modes or ICCs consistently across Mac and Windows for the same printer.
3. When multiple printers are involved, standardize paper and settings to keep B&W output visually aligned.

Sources

• Canon Europe — Professional black & white photo printing guidance
• Epson — Advanced Black and White printing mode (technical guide)
• ILFORD Photo — Black & white print contrast and tonality concepts

Matt ● replies in < 1 min

Technician Expert

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Trusted by 27,000+ customers

Alex · Expert's Assistant

Start Chat

5 Tech Support Specialists are online right now.